- Home
- Comparisons
- Canned water vs bottled water
Canned water vs bottled water
Is water in a can better than water in a plastic bottle?
The verdict
A can changes the container wall, but often retains an internal coating that needs its own declaration. The cited entries do not establish a matched Liquid Death-versus-Aquafina particle ranking. Aluminium outside the water-contact layer is not evidence that the finished drink contains no polymer particles.
Aluminium can with a thin epoxy or acrylic internal liner
Editorial contact/evidence index
Lightweighted PET (#1) bottle with a polypropylene cap
Editorial contact/evidence index
These carry different evidence grades. Liquid Death is grade C and Aquafina is grade A. Measurement context contributes to this editorial index. A lower total can reflect missing evidence rather than lower release. Neither the score gap nor the grades establish a dose difference. Read the model limitations →
Where they actually differ
| Liquid Death | Aquafina | |
|---|---|---|
| Container to document | Can body, interior coating and closure | Bottle body and cap |
| Cited measurement | No brand-specific particle result established by this entry | Sampled-brand bottled-water evidence; not Qian’s unnamed brands |
| Source question | Exact liner and current product specification | Exact package, lot and sampled conditions |
| Health or dose ranking | Not established by material inventory alone | Not established by material inventory alone |
Where this comparison stops being reliable
Glass packaging is not a zero-particle reference either. Schymanski et al.’s packaging-group means and blank controls do not prove a universal glass advantage or assign all detected particles to caps and filling equipment.
The full picture on each
Does Liquid Death have microplastics?
Much less than a plastic bottle, and not zero. Aluminium cannot shed microplastic, which removes the bottle-wall problem entirely. What remains is a thin polymer liner between the metal and the water, so the can swaps a particle question for a liner-chemistry one.
Full score breakdown and sources →
Does Aquafina have microplastics?
Yes, and this one has actually been measured. Aquafina was one of the eleven brands in the 2018 Mason study, which found microplastic in 93% of the 259 bottles it tested across those brands, averaging 325 particles per litre.
Full score breakdown and sources →
Neither of these is what you own
Review available packaging details for the product you own, then inspect its actual parts and care instructions. An app assessment does not measure the particles released by that individual item.